The lyrics of "All This (And More)" speak to a sense of distance, regret, and longing for someone who was once close but is now far away. The protagonist remembers the initial connection with this person and struggles with the idea of forgetting them amidst feelings of missing their unique brand of chaos.

Meaning of "All This (And More)" by Against Me!

The lyrics of "All This (And More)" capture a complex mix of emotions surrounding a past relationship. The distance of one hundred sixty miles to Cincinnati serves as a physical representation of the emotional gap between the protagonist and the person they are reminiscing about. The use of a "Plastic Christ" symbolizes a sense of brokenness and perhaps a loss of faith in the relationship. The protagonist reflects on memories of intimacy and connection, while also acknowledging the need to forget and move on. The reference to French girls from Jacksonville hints at a transient, almost surreal element to the relationship, adding a layer of mystique to the lyrics. Ultimately, the song conveys a bittersweet nostalgia for a person who brought chaos and excitement into the protagonist's life, leaving them grappling with the conflicting desires of wanting to forget yet also remembering the intensity of the connection.