Meaning of "In Common" by Alicia Keys

The lyrics of "In Common" explore the complexities of a relationship where two people have a lot in common, but also have their own personal struggles. The speaker mentions wanting to leave early in the morning but finding themselves still in their partner's bed. This signifies a pattern of being unable to let go and saying goodbye, hinting at a deeper emotional attachment. The line "Goodnight usually means goodbye" suggests that the speaker often finds themselves holding onto memories and replaying them in their mind, implying that they struggle with letting go of the past.

The recurring question "Who are you?" emphasizes a sense of confusion and uncertainty in the relationship. The speaker finds their partner familiar but also questions their authenticity. This demonstrates how the speaker may have doubts and reservations about the true nature of their connection, further highlighting the complexity of their relationship.

The chorus reflects the speaker's realization that they have too much in common with their partner. They express their honesty about this fact, acknowledging the shared experiences and similarities between them. However, the repeated line "you must be messed up too" suggests a self-awareness of their own flaws and insecurities. The speaker questions if someone would truly want to love someone like them, implying a lack of self-worth or belief that they are deserving of love.

The lyrics also suggest a shift in the relationship over time. The speaker mentions how they used to talk until midnight and spend time together when they were younger. However, now their interactions seem more sporadic, with the possibility of a text message in the future that may or may not receive a reply. This shift highlights the changing nature of their relationship and hints at a lack of stability or commitment.

Ultimately, "In Common" delves into the complexities and challenges of a relationship where two individuals have a lot in common but also carry their own personal baggage. The song explores themes of self-worth, trust, and emotional vulnerability, showcasing the struggles that can arise in relationships when both individuals have their own issues to contend with.