Meaning of "Is This Thing Cursed?" by Alkaline Trio

The lyrics of "Is This Thing Cursed?" by Alkaline Trio explore the idea of being trapped in a cycle of bad luck or negativity. The narrator is frustrated and overwhelmed by the persistent presence of this "cursed" thing in their life. The repetition of the question "Is this thing cursed?" reflects the narrator's attempt to make sense of the unfortunate events that keep occurring.

The frustration and despair expressed in the lyrics convey a sense of powerlessness. The narrator tries to distance themselves from the cursed thing by throwing it in the river, but it only reappears in their life, symbolized by it washing up in their sink. This illustrates the feeling of being unable to escape or break free from the negative influences that plague them.

Throughout the song, there is a sense of resignation and acceptance of the curse. The line "Maybe it's some kind of spell that I've been living under" suggests that the narrator has come to believe that they are fated to endure these hardships. The mention of collecting coins near a "nightmare wishing well" implies that the narrator is aware of their own participation in this cycle, as they continue to make wishes or take actions that perpetuate the curse.

The bridge introduces the idea of trying to leave it all behind, but nearly blowing up in the car suggests that escape is not as simple as it seems. This further emphasizes the feeling that the curse is inescapable and even dangerous to confront directly.

Ultimately, "Is This Thing Cursed?" captures the frustration and resignation that can come from being stuck in a cycle of negativity or bad luck. It conveys the struggle of trying to understand and break free from this cycle, while also exploring the complex emotions that arise from feeling trapped and powerless.