Meaning of "Are You Serious" by Andrew Bird

"Are You Serious" delves into the complexities of romantic relationships, particularly focusing on the need for sincerity and commitment. The opening lines establish the protagonist's history of always wanting more and being noncommittal. They acknowledge their own tendency to be obscure or complicated in communication, using semantics as a way to avoid clarity. However, the lyrics emphasize a shift towards boldness and authenticity, as the protagonist expresses a desire to be straightforward and genuine in their expressions. The repeated question "Are you serious?" serves as a challenge to the partner, asking them to prove the depth of their feelings and their willingness to fight for the relationship. The reference to the boyfriend leaving to get a beer suggests that there may be an opportunity for the protagonist to connect more deeply with the person they are addressing. The plea for the partner to not look away signifies a call for open and honest communication, with a refusal to accept excuses or meaningless explanations. Overall, the song explores the universal need for sincerity, commitment, and genuine connection in relationships.