Meaning of "Why?" by Andrew Bird

The song "Why?" by Andrew Bird delves into themes of frustration and longing for a more intense and passionate relationship. The narrator expresses their confusion and exasperation towards someone who has shown unwavering forgiveness and easygoing nature. The repetition of "Why?" throughout the song highlights the narrator's desire for an explanation for this person's lack of emotional response. They question why this person hasn't punished or confronted them for their mistakes, suggesting that such a reaction would have been expected in a more fiery and passionate romance. The narrator also expresses a wish for the easygoing person to show some temper or anger, emphasizing their frustration with the lack of intensity in their relationship. They long for a more dynamic and explosive connection, rather than the calm and forgiving nature of their partner. The lyrics convey a sense of yearning for conflict and emotional intensity, suggesting that the narrator may feel unfulfilled and bored by the easygoing nature of their relationship.