Meaning of "I'd Tell You But..." by Anti-Flag

The lyrics of "I'd Tell You But..." by Anti-Flag convey a strong anti-war sentiment and condemn the violence committed during an invasion. The song critiques the invasion as a crime, suggesting that the justifications used by those behind it are deceitful. The narrator expresses their anger and refusal to be won over by the invasion, stating that the killing of their family does not lead to support but rather fuels their resentment. The line "Keep it for your United States" implies that the narrator rejects the idea of the invasion being done on behalf of their country, challenging the idea that it represents freedom.

The song also highlights the personal toll of war. The narrator laments the loss of their own life, stating that they can no longer experience the things they once loved, such as reading, writing poetry, being with friends and family, and enjoying the beauty of nature. The repetition of "I'm dead" emphasizes the finality of death and the irrevocable damage caused by the violence. The lyrics also suggest that the narrator's spirit will continue to haunt those responsible, both in their waking and sleeping moments, symbolizing the lasting impact and guilt that war brings.

"I'd Tell You But..." serves as a scathing critique of war and its consequences. It challenges the justifications used for invading other countries and exposes the human cost of such actions. The song implies that violence begets violence, as the narrator's death only fuels their determination to haunt and remind the invaders of their actions. It ultimately calls for accountability and warns about the long-lasting effects of war on both the individual and society as a whole.