Meaning of "Shut Up" by Anya Marina

The lyrics of "Shut Up" by Anya Marina speak to the complexities of romantic relationships and the internal conflict that can arise when two people feel a strong connection but are unsure of how to navigate it. The narrator acknowledges the reasons why a relationship between them may be deemed inappropriate or difficult, but ultimately pleads for the other person to stop overthinking and let their emotions take the lead. The repetition of the phrase "shut up, kiss me like you mean it" reflects a desire for authenticity and passion in their interaction, despite the potential risks involved. The lyrics also delve into themes of vulnerability, trust, and the uncertainty that comes with opening up to love. The reference to folding a heart into a paper plane and sending it across the Hudson symbolizes the hope that their feelings will be reciprocated and returned to them intact, but also the fear of rejection or losing something valuable in the process. Overall, the song captures the thrill and fear of falling for someone and the internal struggle that can come with it.