Meaning of "What If" by Ashley Tisdale

The lyrics of "What If" delve into themes of trust, commitment, and fear of abandonment within a romantic relationship. The narrator expresses her disappointment and disbelief at her partner's behavior, noting that their situation feels wrong. She had expected him to be by her side, but instead, he seems ready to give up and never turn around. This lack of reliability and dedication causes the narrator to question the authenticity of his feelings.

The chorus of the song poses hypothetical scenarios, emphasizing the narrator's uncertainty about the future of their relationship. She wonders if she could count on him to save her if she needed him or if he would find a lame excuse to avoid being true to her. Similarly, she questions whether he would be the one to fight for their love or simply watch her walk away without making any effort. These questions highlight the narrator's inner turmoil and desire for reassurance and commitment from her partner.

The lyrics also touch on the narrator's frustration at constantly worrying about her partner's tendency to quit over anything. She feels as though she could easily lose him, as he seems willing to let go at the slightest inconvenience. This sense of insecurity causes the narrator to doubt his ability to distinguish between the good and bad aspects of their relationship. She recognizes the hurt she feels due to his actions and comments on his lack of understanding.

Overall, "What If" explores the complexities of a relationship where one partner harbors doubts and fears about the other's commitment. It showcases the importance of trust, communication, and reliability in maintaining a healthy and strong bond. The lyrics portray the internal struggle of the narrator as she contemplates whether her partner will be there for her and if their love is strong enough to withstand challenges.