The lyrics describe a relationship between two people who see themselves as different from the norm, with the male protagonist working as an undercover cop in a shop and the female protagonist being in an all-girl band living above her dad's garage. Despite their unconventional lives, they express their love for each other and their desire to escape the monotony of their current situation.

Meaning of "Alternative Girlfriend" by Barenaked Ladies

"Alternative Girlfriend" by Barenaked Ladies captures the essence of two individuals who feel out of place in society and find solace in each other's company. The song celebrates non-conformity and the freedom to be oneself, even if it means not fitting into traditional roles or expectations. The reference to being "old at being young, young at being old" reflects a sense of disillusionment with societal norms and a desire to break free from them. The lyrics suggest a longing for something more, a desire to escape the mundane and seek a life that is more fulfilling and authentic. The theme of escapism is prevalent throughout the song, with the protagonists dreaming of leaving their current circumstances behind and starting fresh together. Overall, "Alternative Girlfriend" is a love letter to those who march to the beat of their own drum and a reminder that true happiness comes from being true to oneself.