Meaning of "You May Be Right" by Billy Joel

"You May Be Right" delves into the theme of embracing one's unconventional nature and finding compatibility with someone who appreciates it. The lyrics paint a picture of a rebellious individual who takes risks and enjoys living life to the fullest. The narrator recounts various instances of this wild behavior, like crashing someone's party, riding a motorcycle in the rain, and walking through a dangerous neighborhood alone. Despite warnings from others, the narrator survives these escapades and believes it demonstrates their own sanity, which may be a form of self-justification.

The song also explores the complex dynamics of a relationship with someone who understands and accepts the narrator's eccentricities. The narrator describes encountering their partner in an "electric chair" (possibly a metaphor for a lonely state of mind) and uses humor as a means to connect with them. They acknowledge that both partners may be seen as "crazy" by society's standards, but there is an understanding that this compatibility is what makes their connection strong.

There is an underlying sense of defiance and self-assuredness in the lyrics. The narrator challenges the judgment and expectations of others, asserting that they may be wrong in their perceptions. They suggest that despite their unconventional nature, they are content and fulfilled in their relationship. The song ultimately celebrates the uniqueness and compatibility between two people who may be considered outcasts or "lunatics" by society, finding solace and happiness in their connection.