The protagonist reflects on his relationship with a mysterious woman, contemplating the lack of communication and understanding between them. He recalls a past life where she held power and suggests that neither of them can truly know or comprehend the other. He then recounts a lesson learned from a stranger about justice and the need for balance. The protagonist observes two men waiting on a train platform and contemplates the transience of life, confident that the woman will still be asleep when he returns. In the final verse, the protagonist continues his journey alone, acknowledging the disconnect between his actions and his true desires.

Meaning of "I And I" by Bob Dylan

"I And I" captures Bob Dylan's introspective musings on the complexities of communication, relationships, and self-discovery. The song highlights the difficulty of truly understanding and connecting with another person, as demonstrated by the lack of dialogue and shared experiences between the protagonist and the woman he sleeps with. The mention of a past life suggests that their souls may have crossed paths in different forms, but their connection remains elusive. This notion is reinforced by the repetition of "I and I," emphasizing the separation and difference between individuals. The protagonist's decision to go for a walk instead of engaging in conversation reveals his avoidance of emotional connection and the fear of exposing his true self.

The idea of justice and the concept of an "eye for an eye, tooth for a tooth" are introduced through the stranger's teachings. This implies that the protagonist has learned the necessity for balance and consequence, acknowledging that actions have repercussions. This lesson challenges his previous inclination towards detachment, urging him to consider the consequences of his own actions and how they affect others.

The scene at the train platform serves as a contemplation of mortality and the transient nature of life. The protagonist's assurance that the woman will still be asleep when he returns suggests a sense of stability and continuity amidst the uncertainties of the world. However, this tranquility is juxtaposed with the protagonist's lonely journey, pushing himself along the road and navigating the darkness. The final verse implies that the protagonist has taken on the burdens of others, crafting shoes for everyone but neglecting his own needs. This selflessness emphasizes the disparity between his actions and his internal desires, further exploring the theme of disconnection and self-awareness.