Meaning of "A Promise To Keep" by Brandi Carlile

"A Promise To Keep" portrays a complex emotional journey of heartbreak and the longing for reconciliation. The speaker's subconscious remains tied to the person they have lost, as they continue to communicate with them in their sleep. However, the pain runs so deep that they are unable to express their true feelings. The imagery of the moon and the stars represents the extent of their devotion, but their love is not reciprocated. The hill they describe symbolizes the challenges they face in moving forward. Despite the steepness of their journey, they still hold onto hope, hoping to find a promise that even they cannot fulfill.

The lyrics also depict the speaker's struggle to cope with the void left by the loss. Their side of the bed remains untouched, emphasizing their loneliness and longing for companionship. They find temporary solace in dancing alone, attempting to fill the emptiness left behind. Memories continuously flood their mind, like a river, highlighting the difficulty of letting go. The metaphor of having "me an ocean before I'm dead" implies their determination to accumulate a vast and deep reservoir of experiences before their time ends.

The repetition of seeking a promise that they cannot keep reflects their yearning to reconnect with their lost love, even if it seems unattainable. There is a sense of desperation and an acknowledgement of their own limitations. The speaker clings to the belief that their words, whispered or prayed, will ultimately reach the recipient. This longing for communication, validation, and reciprocity demonstrates their deep emotional investment.

The final stanza reveals the fragility of the speaker's heart and their vulnerability. Their attempts to move on have been unsuccessful, resulting in a shattered heart and a feeling of being adrift. They express a desire for the other person's heart and extend their own hand, pledging to try their hardest. This demonstrates their commitment to making things work, despite the challenges they face.