Meaning of "What Can I Say" by Carrie Underwood

"What Can I Say" delves into the aftermath of a breakup, where the speaker grapples with unresolved emotions and regrets. They admit to not feeling sorry that the relationship ended, but rather for the way it came to an end. The use of "piercing words" and "eyes are red" suggests a heated exchange during the breakup, causing emotions to run high. The speaker acknowledges their role in the downfall and expresses a sense of longing and guilt.

The lyrics highlight the difficulty of moving on. The phrase "I've picked up the phone a thousand times and tried to dial your number" emphasizes the speaker's persistent desire to reach out to their former partner. However, the phrase "It's been so long, it's never easy" suggests that time has passed since the breakup, making it even harder to reconnect. The comparison of trying to "spin the world the other way" conveys the sheer impossibility of turning back time and undoing the past.

The song also touches on the consequences of the failed relationship. The line "I hate to think all you had of me is a memory I left you" reveals the speaker's fear that they are only remembered for the negative aspects of the relationship and the pain caused. This realization is further emphasized by the reference to the "mess that it turned into," highlighting the regret and guilt felt by the speaker.

Overall, "What Can I Say" explores themes of regret, longing, and the difficulty of moving on after a breakup. It captures the speaker's internal struggle as they grapple with their own mistakes and the consequences they have left behind.