Meaning of "When You Say You Love Me" by Clay Aiken

These lyrics delve into the complex emotions of falling for someone new while harboring past hurts and insecurities. The speaker is wary of being hurt again and questions the authenticity of the love being offered to them. They long for a deep connection but fear being let down once more. The uncertainty and longing for a genuine, lasting relationship are palpable in these lyrics, showcasing the vulnerability and emotional turmoil that can come with opening up to love. The repeated questions throughout the song highlight the speaker's internal struggle and the desire for reassurance and sincerity in their partner's affections.