Meaning of "Which Is It" by Dan Mangan

"Which Is It" by Dan Mangan delves into the complexities of human nature and the contradictory impulses that drive us. The lyrics warn against falling into the trap of distractions that keep us from engaging meaningfully with ourselves and the world around us. The repetition of lines like "Is this new? Is it ancient?" speaks to the cyclical nature of human behavior and our propensity to repeat mistakes from the past. Mangan's reference to "teenaged heroes" growing old highlights the fleeting nature of idols and the importance of looking beyond superficialities for lasting value. The song's exploration of being drawn to chaos, sadness, and unattainable desires reflects the human condition's tendency to gravitate towards what is destructive or unfulfilling. Despite acknowledging these negative tendencies, the song also calls for resilience in facing challenges and trying to keep negativity at bay. Overall, "Which Is It" serves as a reflection on the complexities of existence and the eternal struggle to navigate conflicting impulses and societal pressures.