Meaning of "Thinkin' Problem" by David Ball

The lyrics of "Thinkin' Problem" delve into the theme of obsessive thinking and the struggles that come with it. The protagonist openly admits to having a "thinking problem," which can be interpreted as a metaphor for being unable to let go of someone mentally. The constant thoughts of this person, referred to as a "she," play like a broken record in his mind. He acknowledges that he has attempted to quit thinking about her numerous times, emphasizing that it has become a habit that is difficult to break.

By likening his obsessive thinking to a drinking problem, the song highlights the destructive nature of this persistent thought pattern. Similar to someone unable to stop drinking once they start, the narrator finds himself unable to stop dwelling on the memories and feelings associated with this woman. The repeated lyrics "Fill the glass up to the top, I'll start with loving her, but I don't know when to stop" metaphorically illustrate his inability to control his thoughts, just as he can't control how much he drinks once he starts.

The verses also touch on the power of memories and how they intensify the protagonist's thinking problem. He wakes up with her name on his lips, indicating that thoughts of her are present from the very beginning of his day. Memories, once they emerge, unfold in his mind like an addictive substance. Each memory, like a sip of alcohol, only serves to reinforce his obsession.

Furthermore, the line "Getting stoned all along on my favorite memory" suggests that the protagonist finds solace and comfort in reliving past experiences with this person. These memories act as a form of escapism, allowing him to indulge in the highs associated with their relationship. However, this reliance on the past creates a vicious cycle of thinking, perpetuating his inability to move on from this thinking problem.

In essence, "Thinkin' Problem" explores the torment and cycle of obsessive thinking, drawing parallels between this mental state and addictive behaviors. It offers a glimpse into the inner turmoil of someone who can't stop their mind from constantly replaying memories of a past love.