Meaning of "Chocolate Girl" by Deacon Blue

"Chocolate Girl" delves into the dynamics of a relationship where one person struggles to comprehend the complexities of their partner's emotions and fails to provide the understanding and support that is needed. Alan, the central character in the song, is depicted as someone who views relationships through a superficial lens. He thinks in numbers, only drinks in places where women are modestly dressed, and struggles to trust his own desires and yearnings. His approach to love is largely detached and lacks genuine emotional investment.

Alan's tendency to seek solace in other relationships is driven by his inability to fully comprehend or engage with his current partner. By pursuing "old flames," he attempts to prove his own humanity, failing to recognize the damaging impact of his actions. The song implies that he finds it easier to engage with past relationships because they lack the emotional complexity and vulnerability of his current partner. However, this behavior only further alienates his partner, leaving her feeling broken and consumed by their relationship.

The metaphor of a "chocolate girl" is used to describe the female character in the song. Alan sees her as someone who melts when he touches her, fragile and easily influenced by his actions. However, the reality is that she is broken and swallowed by the intensity of their relationship, her true self concealed and covered in bits of silver. This symbolizes the suppression of her genuine emotions and the pressure to conform to his expectations.

The lyrics allude to the idea that Alan not only fails to understand his partner but also lacks the willingness to fully engage in emotional connection. His fear of emotions and vulnerability prevents him from recognizing the value of their relationship and the need for gentle understanding. Instead, he seeks comfort from old friends, using them as a distraction to avoid facing the complexities of his current relationship.

The song ultimately highlights the importance of understanding, empathy, and emotional connection in relationships. It serves as a cautionary tale, warning against the detrimental effects of emotional detachment and the danger of neglecting the emotional needs of one's partner.