Meaning of "Couldn't Tell" by Dermot Kennedy

The lyrics of "Couldn't Tell" delve into the theme of reminiscence and the bittersweet nature of past relationships. The opening lines suggest a departure and the notion of seeing with open eyes, potentially implying a newfound clarity or perspective obtained from distance. The mention of singing denotes the harmonious nature of the relationship, symbolizing the ease with which the couple connected. However, there is a shift in the following lines, where the absence of birdsong reflects the current state of the relationship – lacking its previous vitality and joy.

The protagonist then explores his journey of self-discovery and the longing for his partner to acknowledge it. The sea becomes a metaphorical figure he envies – vast, deep, and boundless, contrasting with the secrecy and containment of his emotions. The circular ceilings symbolize the dance of their relationship, perhaps suggesting a repetitive cycle they shared. The chorus serves as a plea to recapture the moments of the past, where summers were filled with uncertainty, but the thought of his partner was constant and overwhelming.

The vulnerability and authenticity of the relationship are emphasized in the lines "Not stalling, crawl in, Girl, you knew me well." These lyrics convey a sense of openness and trust, highlighting the level of intimacy they once shared. The forest leaning represents a natural inclination towards their connection, where nature mirrors their bond.

Overall, "Couldn't Tell" navigates the conflicting emotions of longing for a past love while acknowledging the futility of holding onto it. The lyrics display a mix of hope, sadness, and acceptance, as the singer recognizes the inevitability of the relationship's failure yet still clings to the memories and desires for one last embrace.