Meaning of "Middle Names" by Devendra Banhart

"Middle Names" delves into themes of longing, uncertainty, and the ephemeral nature of relationships. The speaker pretends to not know where the person they long for is going, almost as if they are trying to protect themselves from the pain of their absence. The plea for them to return hints at a deep desire for their presence. However, the repeated reference to "the only thing left is a light" suggests that perhaps the relationship has already faded, and only a flicker of hope remains. The speaker's wondering and questioning reveal their internal struggle to let go and move on. The line about the moon's brightness and the person's niceness evokes a sense of awe and wonder, as if the speaker cannot understand why this person has such an impact on them. The mention of seeing the person alone at Walgreens at night adds a layer of melancholy and loneliness. The speaker used to believe that the person would always come back to them, but they now realize that their love belongs to no one. The final lines imagine the person sitting in front of a station in the rain, highlighting the contrast between the speaker's own direction and the person they long for. The rain becomes a symbol of both renewal and separation, intensifying the emotions in the song.

Overall, "Middle Names" captures the bittersweet essence of longing for someone who may no longer be within reach. It explores the complexity of emotions felt when someone you love is no longer a part of your life, yet the memories and desire for their return persist. The lyrics convey a sense of nostalgia, yearning, and the struggle to let go.