Meaning of "A Case Of You" by Diana Krall

"A Case Of You" delves into the complex emotions of a passionate yet tumultuous relationship. The lyrics suggest that the narrator and their lover both have their own struggles and demons, yet they are drawn to each other. The line "I am as constant as a northern star" implies that the lover wants to reassure their commitment, but the narrator is skeptical, questioning where the constant darkness the lover speaks of exists. The mention of the bar indicates the narrator's fear of being consumed by this love, seeking solace in alcohol as a coping mechanism.

The imagery of drawing a map of Canada with the lover's face on it twice represents the profound impact the person has on the narrator's life. It implies that their love is not only all-encompassing but also a defining aspect of their identity, shaping their view of the world.

The metaphor of love being holy wine encapsulates the paradoxical nature of the relationship. The lover is described as tasting both bitter and sweet, symbolizing the highs and lows experienced in their connection. The desire to "drink a case of you" highlights the addictiveness of their love, suggesting that no matter how much they consume, they can't get enough.

The narrator identifies themselves as a lonely painter, suggesting that they find solace and expression in art. The mention of being frightened by the devil and being drawn to those unafraid implies that they are attracted to individuals who challenge them, even if it leads to turmoil. The concept of love touching souls is affirmed, as the narrator acknowledges that the person has left an indelible mark on their being, evident through their art.

The final verse introduces another woman who is familiar with the lover's life and advises the narrator to stay with them, but to be prepared for heartbreak. This serves as a cautionary tale, highlighting the potential pain and sacrifice that may come with loving someone so deeply.

The overall meaning of "A Case Of You" is the exploration of the complexities and contradictions of love. It captures the intense emotions, the struggles, and the addictive nature of a relationship that can simultaneously bring joy and heartache.