Meaning of "I Can't Tell You Why" by Diana Krall

The lyrics of "I Can't Tell You Why" by Diana Krall delve into the complexities of a strained relationship where love is intertwined with challenges and uncertainty. The narrator grapples with the paradox of loving someone deeply while simultaneously struggling to maintain a healthy relationship. The repeated refrain of "I can't tell you why" expresses a sense of confusion and inability to rationalize their feelings and choices. The line "Aren't we the same two people who live through years in the dark?" suggests a shared history of hardships and challenging times that have deepened the connection between the couple. Despite acknowledging that things get "crazy" and "harder than it has to be," the narrator reaffirms their love for their partner. The song touches on themes of love, loyalty, confusion, and the intricacies of intimate relationships where emotions often defy logic.