Meaning of "Lie" by Dream Theater

The meaning behind the lyrics of "Lie" revolves around the struggles within a relationship and the challenges of trust. The protagonist finds themselves in a vulnerable position, physically and emotionally, represented by being at the bottom of a lake and feeling weak. They express a need for their partner to be honest and open, to not deceive or hide their true intentions. The repeated plea of "Don't tell me you wanted me, don't tell me you thought of me" signifies a fear of manipulation and false promises, revealing a past of broken trust.

The mention of Mother Mary adds a layer of religious imagery, contrasting with the theme of doubt. The phrase "Kiss the boys and make them wary" suggests that the protagonist has witnessed or experienced the consequences of deceitful actions. The line "All dogs need a leash and at least I'll forget it" implies a dependence on their partner, despite the fear of potential pain.

The protagonist also admits to being accustomed to a life of despair, but when their partner appears, they hope they can fill the emptiness. However, they are cautious about bringing up certain topics or overwhelming their partner with their past mistakes. The reference to the stepfather implies a complicated family dynamic that may have contributed to the protagonist's struggles with trust.

Overall, "Lie" delves into the complexities of trust and the fear of being deceived or hurt in a relationship. It explores the conflicting emotions of longing for honesty and intimacy while simultaneously fearing the potential pain that truth can bring.