The lyrics describe a conversation between a father figure and a child, warning the child about the harsh realities of the world and advising them to let go of hope in order to grow. The father figure encourages the child to embrace the idea that going against the odds and societal norms is worthwhile, even if others believe they are wrong.

Meaning of "They Were Wrong" by Edward Sharpe & The Magnetic Zeros

"They Were Wrong" by Edward Sharpe & The Magnetic Zeros explores the theme of defying societal expectations and going against the grain to pursue one's own path. The father figure in the lyrics serves as a mentor, teaching the child that embracing different perspectives and taking risks outside of the conventional mindset can lead to growth and personal fulfillment. The reference to "dancing with disease" and "swinging, singing peace" implies that facing challenges head-on and striving for peace in a turbulent world is a valid and noble pursuit, even if it defies the norm. The repetitive refrain of "They are wrong" reinforces the idea that questioning norms and following one's own truth can lead to a fulfilling life, despite others' doubts. Overall, the song's message encourages individuality, resilience, and perseverance in the face of adversity.