Meaning of "Why?" by Elvis Costello

The lyrics of "Why?" by Elvis Costello convey the heartbreaking perspective of a child caught in the middle of a tumultuous family situation. The child's innocent questions reveal a deep sense of confusion, hurt, and longing for stability and love from their parents. The repetition of "Why?" highlights the child's desperation for answers that may never come, as their parents' relationship seems to be characterized by dysfunction and pain. The image of the father being "on fire" suggests a sense of chaos, destruction, and turmoil within the family, further emphasizing the child's feelings of fear and abandonment. Ultimately, the lyrics paint a poignant picture of a child grappling with the complexities of adult relationships and the impact of parental strife on their own sense of security and well-being.