The lyrics depict a sense of defiance and individuality, as the narrator challenges the listener's perception of her identity and refuses to conform to their expectations. She questions what if she is unexpected and contradictory things, highlighting the complexity of her nature and rejecting societal norms.

Meaning of "What If" by Emilie Autumn

"What If" by Emilie Autumn is a powerful anthem of self-discovery and rebellion against societal expectations. The narrator refuses to be defined by others and challenges the listener to see beyond superficial judgments. Themes of individuality, complexity, and defiance run throughout the lyrics, as the narrator explores the idea of being misunderstood and unapologetically unique. By questioning the listener's assumptions and embracing her multifaceted nature, the narrator celebrates the idea of being true to oneself regardless of societal pressures. The repeated questioning of "what if" serves as a reminder that identity is not fixed and can encompass a multitude of contradictions and surprises, urging the listener to break free from limiting stereotypes and embrace their true essence.