Meaning of "Wherefore & Why" by Gordon Lightfoot

"Wherefore & Why" explores the existential ponderings of the narrator, delving into the universal search for meaning and purpose in life. The song begins with a sense of anticipation and hope, with the narrator feeling that the day will hold something significant for them. This sets the stage for a contemplative journey of self-discovery.

The narrator yearns for understanding and seeks to find answers to their questions about life. They are aware of the forces that can shape and impact them, such as the wind, rain, and the actions of others ("brothers forsake me"). These external influences contrast with their inner desire to have a tangible impact on the world ("but can I touch the rain").

The symbolic imagery of the sunrise above the cotton sky and the various individuals going about their daily routines conveys a sense of the beauty and complexity of life. The narrator reflects on their urge to explore and understand "the wherefore and the why." They question the passage of time, feeling lost and unable to distinguish between different seasons.

However, a moment of clarity dawns upon them. They realize that the search for meaning cannot be confined to external factors but resides within themselves. It is in the sun above, representing the natural world and its wonders, and it is also in the love they have for someone. The narrator acknowledges that the reason why one seeks meaning may never be fully known, but the pursuit itself is significant.

In the end, the song acknowledges the inherent uncertainties in life. There is much to be gained and lost, highlighting the bittersweet nature of existence. The melody and the poetic lyrics combine to evoke a sense of introspection and contemplation, inviting listeners to reflect on their own journey for meaning and understand the complex emotions associated with the search.