Meaning of "All But One" by Grace Potter And The Nocturnals

The song "All But One" delves into the complexities of moving on from a past relationship while grappling with the memories that still hold emotional power. The singer acknowledges the fading of love and the reasons they once had for being in the relationship, but there is one memory, symbolized by a glint in the eye, that continues to haunt them. This memory acts as a reminder of the emotional connection they shared with their partner, a connection that remains despite the passage of time. The internal struggle between forgetting and holding onto that one precious memory represents the difficulty of letting go of a past love, even when the relationship has ended. The lyrics capture the bittersweet essence of nostalgia and heartbreak, reflecting on the power of memory to linger long after the relationship has ended.