Meaning of "Tell Me What It Is" by Graham Central Station

The repeated plea of "tell me what it is" in the lyrics conveys a sense of confusion and desperation in trying to understand the motivations and desires of the other person. The speaker seems to be grappling with a lack of fulfillment in their romantic relationship, feeling unappreciated and taken for granted. The mention of wanting security and a ring on the left hand suggests a desire for commitment and stability, and a longing for being treated with respect and care. The contrast between the love the speaker has for their partner and how they are being treated as "second hand" reflects the emotional turmoil and conflict within the relationship. Ultimately, the lyrics paint a picture of someone trying to make sense of a situation where their needs and wants are not being met, and yearning for clarity and understanding from their partner.