Meaning of "Cookie Jar" by Gym Class Heroes

The lyrics of "Cookie Jar" can be seen as a metaphor for the temptations and vices that people face in relationships. The cookie jar represents all the enticing opportunities and pleasures that may arise outside of a committed relationship. The speaker acknowledges their attraction to other people ("I like girls, they like me") and the desire to remain faithful, but they repeatedly fail to resist the temptations ("Can't keep my hands out the cookie jar"). This highlights the internal struggle between loyalty and the desire for novelty or variety in relationships.

The lyrics also touch on the use of deception and lying ("I left crumbs in the bed once but I told her I was through with that") to cover up one's actions and betrayals. This showcases the guilt and shame that can come with succumbing to temptation, as the speaker feels the need to hide their actions from their partner. However, despite their efforts to deceive, their partner remains suspicious and unconvinced.

Furthermore, the specific types of cookies mentioned throughout the song could symbolize the different types of people or experiences that tempt the speaker. Each cookie represents a unique flavor or characteristic that entices the speaker, regardless of the associated ethnicity or background ("Butter Pecan, Puerto Rican, or them Oatmeal Raisin Asians, Hazelnut Brazilians, Macadamia Caucasians"). The mention of these cookie flavors highlights the diversity of temptations that the speaker encounters, emphasizing the struggle to maintain monogamy.

Overall, "Cookie Jar" explores the complex emotions and challenges that can arise within relationships, particularly when faced with external temptations. It speaks to the difficulty of staying faithful and the internal battle between desires and commitments.