Meaning of "Good Sister/Bad Sister" by Hole

The lyrics of "Good Sister/Bad Sister" explore the complicated dynamics of a relationship between two sisters. The use of contrasting adjectives, such as "good" and "bad," highlights the complexities and contradictions within their bond. The lyrics suggest a sense of resentment and envy, as the narrator urges their sister to burn her dress, symbolizing a desire to shed the trappings of conventionality and conformity. The scar tissue and blood blisters mentioned further emphasize the wounds and pain inflicted in their relationship.

There is a recurring theme of longing and frustration present throughout the song. The repetition of the lines "I can't and I want to so bad, and I try but I can't" reflects the narrator's struggle to reconcile conflicting emotions and desires. It illustrates the inability to let go of the past and move forward.

The lyrics also convey a sense of power dynamics and manipulation. The line "Sell me down the river, sister" implies betrayal and exploitation within the relationship. The narrator feels used and discarded, left to suffer the consequences of their sister's actions.

The reference to choking and being choked on "big black bloody mouthfuls" symbolizes the stifling nature of the relationship. It suggests a suffocating feeling of being overwhelmed and consumed by their sister's dominance and control.

The repeated mention of scars and being the "biggest scar" signifies the lasting impact and trauma caused by their sister. It represents the emotional wounds that cannot be healed or forgotten, serving as a reminder of the toxic aspects of their relationship.

Overall, "Good Sister/Bad Sister" delves into themes of resentment, longing, power dynamics, and the lasting effects of toxic relationships. It portrays the complexities of familial bonds and the struggles faced when trying to break free from the past.