Meaning of "Extraordinary" by Idina Menzel

The lyrics of "Extraordinary" delve into the theme of missed opportunities and unrequited love. The singer reflects on the past and the connection they shared with someone, wondering if it could have evolved into something more significant. Being intoxicated adds a layer of vulnerability to the confession, as they reach out to the person they hold in high regard, regardless of their current status. The lyrics suggest that time has not diminished the impact this person had on the singer's life, proven by the butterflies and the memorable moments that remain ingrained in their memory.

The song captures the bittersweet feeling of longing for a missed chance and wondering what could have been. It addresses the universal human desire for closure and the need to express emotions that have been kept hidden for years. The repetition of the line "I always wonder if we could've been something" emphasizes the lingering presence of this person's memory in the singer's life. It signifies a need for resolution and a longing to understand if the other person ever thinks of them in the same way.

The lyrics also touch on feelings of inadequacy and regret, with the singer acknowledging their own mistakes and growth since the time they were together. This adds complexity to the song, as it becomes a reflection not only on the missed opportunity but also on personal growth and the changes that occur over time.

Ultimately, "Extraordinary" explores the uncertain nature of past relationships and the "what if" questions that can haunt someone's thoughts. It conveys a sense of longing and a desire for closure, while also acknowledging the possibility that the other person may have completely moved on. The song encapsulates the complex emotions that accompany unrequited love and serves as an anthem for those who still wonder about the roads not taken.