Meaning of "Mystery" by Indigo Girls

In "Mystery," the Indigo Girls delve into the intricacies of a challenging relationship. The opening lines express the uncertainty and longing associated with not knowing when they will see the other person again. It is clear that this person has taken up residence in the protagonist's thoughts, making their thinking crowded. The image of the barking dogs in the background suggests a restlessness and turmoil within their emotions.

The protagonist then contemplates the nature of love. They question if love is determined or if it is a matter of choice. They wonder if love has the power to endure through time like the ancient hymns or if it is merely a fleeting pop emotion. The uncertainty continues as they ponder if love's departure implies that it was never real to begin with. These questions reflect the doubts and fears that can arise when love is complicated and unpredictable.

The lyrics also touch on the allure of danger and the desire to prove oneself. The protagonist describes their companion as someone who revels in danger and enjoys the taste of it on their lips. They are willing to stand in the line of fire to showcase their skill. While the protagonist struggles to identify what they would be willing to die for, they acknowledge that not everything needs to be spoken aloud, especially in the presence of this person.

The imagery of a pirate getting the ship and the girl alludes to the idea of seizing opportunities and taking risks. The girl, referred to as a "very good listener," is drawn to the excitement and adventure. This suggests that the protagonist's companion is someone who thrives on the thrill of the unknown and enjoys being part of daring escapades.

Despite the differences between the protagonist and their companion, the song concludes with the realization that they are equal partners in a mystery. It suggests that the mystery lies in their relationship itself, their ability to meet in the middle of impossibility, and find a balance between their opposing natures. While the specifics of their connection may remain unclear, they are united by their shared experience of navigating the complexities of love and life.