Meaning of "I Love You So Much It's Killing Us Both" by Jawbreaker

"I Love You So Much It's Killing Us Both" explores the turbulent nature of a relationship and the internal struggle of the narrator. The repeated line "Should we get married or just go on killing each other?" highlights the conflicting emotions and the uncertainty of whether they should stay together or separate. There is a sense of ambivalence and confusion throughout the lyrics, with the narrator expressing their love for the other person but questioning if it is enough to sustain a healthy relationship.

The line "How can I save you when I couldn't save a dime" reflects a feeling of helplessness and inadequacy. The narrator acknowledges their own flaws and doubts their ability to support their partner. This may contribute to the toxic dynamics of the relationship, as both individuals seem to rely heavily on each other for happiness.

The mention of wanting a life without parties suggests a desire for simplicity and stability. Parties are often associated with chaos and excess, and the narrator longs for a more peaceful existence. This could be seen as a metaphor for wanting a relationship without drama and constant ups and downs.

The lyrics also touch on the theme of gender identity with the line "Sometimes I catch myself thinking, 'Boy, or girl?'" This line suggests that the narrator is questioning their own identity and grappling with understanding their own preferences.

The overall meaning of the song seems to be an examination of the complexities of love and the pain it can bring. The narrator loves the other person deeply, but this love is causing both of them harm. It raises the question of whether love is worth the suffering it can bring and whether it is possible to find a balance in a tumultuous relationship.