Meaning of "Pirates" by Jenny Owen Youngs

"Pirates" by Jenny Owen Youngs delves into a toxic relationship dynamic where the singer finds themselves returning to someone who doesn't necessarily bring them happiness but also doesn't cause them further harm. The metaphor of being pirates or seeking privacy illustrates the desire to escape reality and find solace in someone else, even if it's transient. The cycle of emotional turmoil is evident as the singer describes being unable to articulate their feelings, feeling lost and unable to stand on their own. The choice of numbness over pain reflects a coping mechanism to deal with the hurt caused by the relationship. The song also touches on the theme of self-preservation, where the singer acknowledges that what is hidden or unseen can't hurt them, emphasizing the need to protect oneself from further damage. Ultimately, the lyrics portray a sense of resilience mixed with a hint of resignation, as the singer understands the need to let go despite the lingering pain.