Meaning of "You Were Good" by Jimmy Eat World

The lyrics of "You Were Good" delve into the complexities of love and loss in a relationship that held promise but ultimately ended in heartache. The singer grapples with the realization that despite loving their partner deeply, it was not enough to sustain the relationship. The mention of the partner's charm reminding them of someone else insinuates possible infidelity or emotional unavailability on their part. The singer acknowledges that they may not have been exactly what the partner wanted, but the intensity of their feelings remains strong. The repetition of "it was good, then it was gone" conveys a sense of longing and nostalgia for what once was. The lyrics capture the bittersweet nature of relationships, where love is not always enough to make things work, and sometimes, despite best intentions, things come to an end.