Meaning of "What You Are" by Joan Osborne

The song "What You Are" by Joan Osborne delves into themes of self-reflection, identity, and acceptance. The image of the ladies dancing by the lake prompts the listener to question their own desires and wishes. The repeated question of "what do you wish you were?" invites introspection into one's aspirations and innermost desires. The lyrics suggest that perhaps what one seeks is already within themselves, highlighted by the idea of being the light of every star. This symbolizes the idea that each individual possesses their own unique brilliance and worth. The repeated refrain of "nobody knows but maybe that's just what you are" emphasizes the idea that sometimes we already embody the qualities we seek, we just need to realize and accept them. Overall, the song encourages listeners to embrace who they are and recognize their intrinsic value.