Meaning of "Perfectly Good Guitar" by John Hiatt

The song "Perfectly Good Guitar" by John Hiatt criticizes famous musicians who intentionally destroy their instruments during performances. Hiatt expresses his sadness and frustration at witnessing these acts, describing the guitars as "perfectly good" and highlighting their value. The lyrics suggest that the act of smashing guitars is a symbol of arrogance and a lack of respect for art and craftsmanship. Hiatt refers to these musicians as "stars" and questions their motives, wondering who they think they are to destroy something so precious. The song also delves into the personal history of the protagonist, who recalls his own desire for a new guitar in 1963 and settling for a cracked sunburst model. The lingering disappointment in not being able to obtain the guitar of his dreams serves as a parallel to the destruction inflicted on perfectly good guitars by famous musicians. Hiatt emphasizes the emotional connection between a musician and their instrument, referring to it as a girlfriend and expressing the pain of losing something so beloved. He suggests that the act of destroying a guitar is akin to losing a part of oneself. In the final verse, Hiatt suggests that there should be consequences for those who destroy guitars, proposing a law that would send such individuals to jail without bail. He believes this punishment would serve as a way to enforce respect for artistry and ensure that the act of destroying a guitar carries consequences. The song ends with a lament for the loss of the old guitar and a desire to hold it once again, symbolizing a longing for what was lost and a recognition of the irreplaceable nature of these instruments.