Meaning of "Who Did You Think I Was" by John Mayer

"Who Did You Think I Was" delves into the concept of self-identity and the multitudes that exist within a person. The speaker begins by highlighting their enigmatic nature, possessing only half a smile and no shame. They hint at having a different persona reflected in their actions, as if they possess dual identities. This suggests that they are not easily defined or understood.

The lyrics continue to delve into the speaker's fluidity and ever-changing mindset. Each morning, they make up their mind but quickly change it back, signifying their unpredictability and adaptability. They describe themselves as a "shifter of the shape," implying that they continuously mold themselves to fit various situations and personas.

The variations in the speaker's identity are questioned by others, as they ask, "Who did you think I was?" This suggests that people may have preconceived notions about the speaker and their character. The speaker challenges these assumptions by asserting that even though others may have their "number," they have always known the score. It implies that others may believe they understand the speaker, but in reality, they do not fully grasp the complexity of their true self.

The lyrics also explore the speaker's talent and role as an artist. They question if they are the one who plays the quiet songs, potentially referring to their introspective and emotional side. They juxtapose this with the possibility of someone else, referred to as "He," who possesses the ability to seduce and captivate others. This suggests that the speaker may be multifaceted, capable of evoking different emotions and reactions from people.

In the final lines, the speaker presents themselves as someone who carries the weight of the world in the palm of their hand. This metaphor symbolizes their strength and ability to handle challenges and responsibilities. It implies that despite their complex nature, they are capable of managing and navigating life's difficulties.

Overall, "Who Did You Think I Was" explores themes of self-identity, perception, and the multifaceted nature of human beings. It challenges preconceived notions and invites others to question their assumptions about who someone truly is.