Meaning of "Dear Abby" by John Prine

The lyrics of "Dear Abby" convey a message of self-acceptance and the futility of wishing for a different life. Through the various letters, the narrator expresses their dissatisfaction with different aspects of their life, like physical appearance, family problems, and embarrassing situations. However, Dear Abby's response implies that these complaints are futile and that the narrator should embrace their life as it is. The message of the song can be seen as an encouragement to stop dwelling on perceived problems and instead focus on finding contentment with oneself.

The repetition of the phrase "You are what your are and you ain't what you ain't" reinforces the idea that individuals should accept their current circumstances and not wish for something different. By responding with this phrase after each complaint, Dear Abby dismisses the idea that external circumstances are the source of happiness or fulfillment. Instead, the song suggests that true contentment comes from within and that it is important to appreciate what one has.

The humorous and lighthearted tone of the song adds to its message of self-acceptance. Despite the various complaints presented in the letters, the overall tone remains playful and light. This tone helps to convey a message that even though life may have its challenges and imperfections, it is important to maintain a positive and accepting outlook.

In a broader sense, "Dear Abby" may also be commenting on the human tendency to focus on the negative aspects of life and overlook the positives. By addressing common complaints and offering a simple yet profound response, the song encourages listeners to shift their perspective and find contentment in their present circumstances.