The lyrics describe a woman who has moved on from a past lover and refuses to entertain his attempts to reconnect, changing her phone number to avoid his calls and asserting her independence.

Meaning of "Mistaken Identity" by Kim Carnes

The lyrics of "Mistaken Identity" by Kim Carnes depict a woman who has clearly been hurt by a former lover and is determined not to fall back into his trap. She has taken steps to ensure that he cannot reach her, symbolizing her desire to break free from the toxic relationship. The repetition of the phrase "Must be a case of mistaken identity, I'm not the girl you want me to be" emphasizes her newfound self-awareness and strength. By refusing to be manipulated or controlled by her ex, she asserts her own autonomy and self-worth. Ultimately, the song conveys a message of empowerment and liberation from a past that no longer serves her.