Meaning of "Why Don't You Try" by Leonard Cohen

In "Why Don't You Try," Leonard Cohen delves into the theme of self-empowerment within relationships, urging someone to consider the possibility of living without their significant other. The speaker questions the listener's reliance on their partner, challenging them to evaluate their own needs and desires. By asking if the listener truly needs their partner's hands for their passion, their heart for their throne, their labor for their baby, or their beast for their bone, Cohen highlights the dependency and power dynamics at play. He suggests that the listener's worth and identity as a woman should not be tied to the control or possession of another person. Cohen encourages the listener to open up their hand and let go of their partner, reminding them that life offers many other potential companions and experiences. He contrasts the idea of being the ditch around a tower or the moonlight in someone's cave, passive roles that serve someone else's existence, with the possibility of embracing their own power and agency. Cohen uses vivid imagery to convey the idea of breaking free from societal expectations and gender roles, prompting the listener to resist and challenge traditional norms.

The lyrics also touch upon the concept of commitment and the difficulties that arise within a relationship. Cohen introduces the story of Jack and Jill, two individuals who have embraced their mutual misery and are about to embark on a ceremony. By mentioning the need for everyone to pray, Cohen emphasizes the weight and seriousness of their commitment. He suggests that their vows are both challenging and binding, and that they have willingly chosen to dedicate themselves to one another. The line "let nobody put a loophole, a loophole in their way" suggests that the speaker respects and admires this kind of unwavering dedication. Cohen's lyrics ultimately serve as a reminder to the listener that they can find fulfillment and strength within themselves, rather than relying on others for their happiness or sense of self-worth.