Meaning of "Why Can't I?" by Liz Phair

The lyrics of "Why Can't I?" explore the exhilaration and frustration of infatuation and forbidden love. The narrator describes the initial stages of a connection with someone new, feeling a strong attraction and a sense that they were meant to be together. However, there are obstacles in the form of existing relationships. Both the narrator and the person they desire have partners, which creates a conflict between their desires and the moral boundaries they should follow.

The narrator expresses their frustration at not being able to control their thoughts and emotions, as they constantly think about this person they hardly know. The repetition of the lines "Why can't I breathe whenever I think about you? Why can't I speak whenever I talk about you?" illustrates the overwhelming nature of their infatuation. It consumes their every thought and leaves them feeling breathless and speechless.

The lyrics suggest that the narrator recognizes the thrill of finding someone new after a breakup ("Isn't this the best part of breakin' up? Finding someone else you can't get enough of"). They describe this feeling as an itch that needs to be scratched, acknowledging the temporary nature of their desires but still finding beauty in the experience.

The chorus emphasizes the inevitability of their connection progressing physically ("It's inevitable, it's a fact that we're gonna get down to it"). The narrator acknowledges the excitement and anticipation they feel, even though they haven't yet engaged in a sexual relationship ("We haven't fucked yet, but my head's spinning"). This anticipation creates a sense of urgency, making it difficult for them to control their desires and thoughts.

The final lines of the song express a desire for the unknown and the potential for a deeper connection ("I'd love for you to make me wonder where it's goin', I'd love for you to pull me under, somethin's growin'"). Despite the complications and the risk of being hurt, the narrator is drawn to the unpredictable nature of this relationship.

Ultimately, "Why Can't I?" delves into the exhilaration and frustration that comes with forbidden love and infatuation. It captures the overwhelming emotions and desires that can arise when two people feel a strong attraction, even when they know it is morally or practically wrong.