Meaning of "Butterfly" by Lloyd Cole

In "Butterfly," Lloyd Cole explores the themes of innocence, transformation, and longing. The lyrics begin by describing the subject as an innocent child before the protagonist's influence entered their life. The pain that was hidden within the subject began to bloom, symbolizing a metamorphosis from innocence to experiencing the trials and tribulations of life. The mention of a darkened room implies that this transformation occurred in a place of secrecy or hidden desires.

The use of the butterfly metaphor throughout the song represents the subject's vulnerability and fragility, akin to a delicate butterfly. The protagonist views the subject's transformation as a flight into the light, where they "came alive." This could suggest that the subject found a sense of self or purpose through this transformation, even though it involved pain.

The second verse contrasts the subject's newfound knowledge of love and pain with the protagonist's own experiences and desires. The comparison of love and pain to alcohol portrays them as intoxicating and addictive. The subject starts to rely on them to numb their pain, seeking that "butterfly feeling" as a temporary escape. However, this reliance leads to broken promises and lies, ultimately causing the subject to fly away.

The final verse reveals the protagonist's vulnerability and longing. Lying in bed, thoughts of the subject consume the protagonist's mind. They reflect on the past love and happiness they shared, wishing to feel that way again. The "unclean thoughts" mentioned suggest a sense of guilt or longing for something that may be forbidden or lost. The protagonist yearns to recapture the "butterfly feeling" that was once present in their relationship.

Overall, "Butterfly" delves into the aspects of innocence, transformation, and longing, depicting the fragility of love and the desire to regain lost happiness.