The lyrics of "Gentlest Hammer" describe a sense of longing and desire for someone. The persona in the song compares themselves to a hammer, gently trying to break through the barriers that separate them from the person they desire. The lyrics evoke imagery of shadows, ships sinking, crying, and a deep yearning to connect with this person.

Meaning of "Gentlest Hammer" by Mason Jennings

The lyrics of "Gentlest Hammer" convey a strong sense of yearning and passion towards someone the persona desires. The repeated refrain of "I am the gentlest hammer" suggests a gentle yet persistent approach towards breaking through the walls that the person has put up. The comparison of the persona to a hammer conveys a sense of determination and a willingness to overcome obstacles in order to be with the person they desire. The imagery of shadows, sinking ships, and crying evokes a sense of emotional depth and intensity in this longing. Overall, the song captures the intensity of feelings that come with desire and the willingness to do whatever it takes to connect with someone on a deeper level.