The lyrics of "NYC Girls" by Matt Mays tell the story of falling for a girl from New York City, getting advice to move on from a wise bartender, and reflecting on the loneliness and memories associated with the city.

Meaning of "NYC Girls" by Matt Mays

The lyrics of "NYC Girls" delve into themes of infatuation, advice, and nostalgia. The protagonist describes being drawn to a New York City girl with eyes that captivate him, only to be warned by a bartender, Kenny, about the futility of pursuing her. Despite this advice, the protagonist struggles to let go, reminiscing about the city's lively past and the haunting memories associated with failed relationships. The song ultimately reflects on the bittersweet allure of New York City and the struggle to move on from someone who may never reciprocate the same feelings.