The narrator has met someone new who resembles their past lover but gives them everything they were missing. They question if their past lover is still holding onto resentment, feeling like they've been wronged for a long time.

Meaning of "Answering Machine" by Matt Nathanson

The lyrics of "Answering Machine" by Matt Nathanson explore the complex feelings of moving on from a past relationship and finding someone new. The narrator compares their new partner to their old one, reflecting on how the new partner fulfills the emotional needs that were lacking in the previous relationship. However, there is still a sense of longing and questioning towards the past lover, wondering if they are still holding onto resentment and defending their actions. The lyrics emphasize the idea of healing and moving forward, with the narrator kissing other lips in search of healing, but acknowledging that it's a difficult process. Overall, the song delves into themes of healing, self-reflection, and letting go of past relationships.