Meaning of "Why" by Melanie C

The lyrics of "Why" delve into the universal experience of heartbreak and self-reflection after a relationship has ended. The singer grapples with the pain of heartbreak, questioning why they are still crying over someone who has hurt them. There is a sense of confusion and resignation as they realize there is nothing else they can do but feel the pain. The repeated question of "why" reflects the need for understanding and closure. The lyrics also touch on feelings of regret and self-blame, as the singer wishes they had read the signs and avoided the heartbreak. The imagery of putting out the stars and shutting out the sun symbolizes a desire to erase the memories and pain associated with the failed relationship. Overall, "Why" captures the emotional turmoil of heartbreak, self-doubt, and the longing for closure and healing.