Meaning of "Pups To Dust" by Modest Mouse

The lyrics of "Pups To Dust" reflect on the journey of self-discovery and the challenges of staying true to one's authentic self. The line "Our hearts don't change from pups to dust" suggests that despite the passage of time, our fundamental nature remains constant. The narrator acknowledges their ability to distinguish right from wrong, emphasizing their inherent sense of morality. However, the following line, "I don't lie very often, but I lie very well," highlights the internal conflict between their desire to be honest and their ability to deceive effectively. This contradiction suggests the complexities of human nature and the struggle to uphold one's values in a world where lying often seems beneficial.

The chorus, "Give it away, take what you need. Love does not cost money, but it ain't free," explores the idea that love requires effort and sacrifice. It cannot be bought or possessed, but it demands emotional investment. The song then delves into the theme of self-perception and the influence of others in shaping our identity. The refrain "We don't belong here, we were just born here" suggests a feeling of disconnection and alienation from the environment one is born into. The repeated phrase "We don't remember, we were just born here" underscores the narrator's sense of detachment and ignorance about their purpose or role in this world.

The line "On my dirty thoughts, the way we feel about what we do is by who has watched us so" delves into the impact of societal expectations on individual thoughts and actions. It suggests that our perception of right and wrong is often influenced by the judgments and scrutiny of others. The song ultimately questions the purpose of existence and the struggle to find meaning in life. The line "If there's some point to this, then which one is mine?" reflects the narrator's anxiousness and uncertainty about their place or purpose in the grand scheme of things.