Meaning of "Big Decisions" by My Morning Jacket

The lyrics of "Big Decisions" delve into the dynamics of a relationship where one person is dependent on the other for making important decisions. The narrator expresses their weariness and frustration at always being expected to take charge and make choices on behalf of the other person. The line "Sit'n round wondering just what the hell to do with your life, Only get one chance but you seem to always think twice" suggests that the person in question is indecisive and lacks the confidence to make big decisions on their own. The repeated statement "You're sweet and sincere, but so ruled by fear" suggests that fear is the underlying factor driving their reliance on the narrator.

The narrator expresses their own hesitations and reluctance to continue fulfilling this role by stating "What do you want me to do? Make all the big decisions for you? 'Cause I can't." This implies that the narrator recognizes their own limitations and understands that they cannot bear the burden of decision-making for someone else. The line "I don't quite feel like faking it again tonight, Don't really feel like saying everything is all right" suggests that the narrator is tired of pretending that everything is fine and is longing for a more equal and independent relationship.

The lyrics also convey a sense of encouragement for the other person to take control and make their own decisions. The lines "Go on do it, If you really, really mean it, Oh don't just hold back then regret it" indicate a desire for the person to step outside their comfort zone and embrace the opportunity to make choices, even if they might make mistakes. The final repetition of "Well I can't" emphasizes the narrator's inability to continue taking on the responsibility of making decisions for the other person.

Overall, "Big Decisions" explores themes of independence, fear, and the challenges that arise when one person becomes overly reliant on another for decision-making. It conveys the narrator's frustration and exhaustion with this dynamic while also encouraging the other person to take agency over their own life choices.