Meaning of "Xmas Curtain" by My Morning Jacket

"Xmas Curtain" appears to delve into the theme of societal expectations and the pressure to conform to certain ideals. The mention of lawbreakers who are criminals yet never break the law can be seen as a commentary on how people are often pushed to unorthodox means to achieve desired outcomes. The Christmas girl in the town square may symbolize a desire for something unattainable or forbidden, with the concept of paying to get behind her curtain representing a willingness to sacrifice morals or integrity for a taste of the forbidden. The lyrics could be highlighting the contradictions and complexities of human nature, the internal struggle between doing what is expected versus following one's own desires.

The song may also comment on the allure of consumerism and materialism, as the thieves in the song are driven by a desire for the finer things in life that they cannot afford. The Christmas setting could further emphasize the pressure to conform to societal expectations around the holiday season, where individuals are bombarded with messages to buy, consume, and fit in. Ultimately, "Xmas Curtain" seems to explore the concept of internal conflict, moral ambiguity, and the lengths to which people will go to chase their desires.